Skip to content

Stories

The Catholic Monarchs and the Church: Zaragoza and the Bulls of 1493

· AI-assisted · · Leer en español
AI-generated illustration, not a period image: folded documents with plain wax seals, closed books and a quill on a desk by a window.
AI-generated illustration based on the sources.

What does the register say about Zaragoza in 1484?

The memorial register credits the Catholic Monarchs with ordering the establishment of the tribunal of the faith in Zaragoza in 1484.1The same passage places an auto de fe at La Seo on 10 May that year, identifies the day as a Sunday and notes that the inquisitor Maestro Julian preached.1

This account, which awaits verification, suggests a link between the monarchs’ authority and the establishment of a religious tribunal, although it does not explain how the decision was made or carried out.1

How does the interpretation of the bulls connect sovereignty and evangelization?

According to a historiographical interpretation awaiting verification, the Alexandrian bulls of 1493 established, in practice, a division of new lands between the Portuguese and the Castilians.2In this reading, the pope officially recognized the Catholic Monarchs’ sovereignty over the new territories and linked that recognition to the mandate to evangelize them.2

This synthesis allows us to examine the relationship between territorial authority and religious mission, but it provides neither the text of the bulls nor details of how evangelization was carried out.2

What conclusions can we draw from these two sources?

Read together, the passages suggest two areas of connection between monarchy and religious authority: royal intervention in establishing a tribunal and papal recognition of sovereignty linked to evangelization.12On their own, they do not prove that both episodes formed part of a single programme.12

How we know

Claims cited: 2 · checked against our sources: 0 · not independently fact-checked: 2.

Sources

  1. The memorial register: the Catholic Kings 'ordered the holy tribunal of the faith placed in Zaragoza in 1484' — and on Sunday 10 May 1484 'the auto de fe was held in the seo', preached by the inquisitor Maestro Julian.

    not independently fact-checked primary source

    Henry Charles Lea, A History of the Inquisition of Spain; vol. 1 cap01#b893cap01#b895

    back to the text

  2. The Alexandrian bulls of 1493 established de facto the division of the new lands between Portuguese and Castilians: the pope officially recognized the Catholic Monarchs' sovereignty over the new territories, with the mandate to evangelize them.

    not independently fact-checked scholarly interpretation

    Mariano González Clavero, Roberto Blanco Andrés, América española. Descubrimiento, conquista y asentamiento OEBPS/Text/part0016.xhtml#b18

    José Luis López-Linares, España. La primera globalización OEBPS/Text/Section0010.xhtml#b35

    back to the text