Skip to content

Stories

Montezuma: power from Tenochtitlan and resistance to his authority

· AI-assisted · · Leer en español
Cotton mantles, cacao baskets and clay pots in a plain courtyard, with a lake in the distance.
AI-generated illustration based on the sources.

Where was the seat of Montezuma's power?

The 1519 account places the seat of Montezuma's Mexica power in Tenochtitlan and records that the people of Zocotlan recognized him as their lord.1That recognition suggests his authority reached beyond the city, although the passage does not say how far.1

Projecting this 1519 account back to 1492 is an inference, not something the text states.1

How did Tlaxcala challenge that power?

The 1519 account describes continuous wars between Montezuma and the Tlaxcalans.2

Another passage, unverified, records that the Tlaxcalans called themselves enemies of Montezuma's Mexicans, who, according to the text, were not to come to Tlaxcala.5

What did arresting the tribute-gatherers mean?

According to an unverified passage, Cortés ordered five of Montezuma's tribute-gatherers arrested and directed that people stop obeying him and paying him tribute.3The sequence of events as told suggests that the arrests challenged both the collection of tribute and Montezuma's authority.3

Another unverified passage relates that Montezuma was told that many lands paid parias and tribute to the King, and that it was customary to give obedience first and hand over parias or tribute afterwards.6This second passage concerns tribute paid to the King; read together, the two passages link obedience and tribute, and the second puts obedience first.36

What did the caciques of Cempoala and the Totonac-speaking lords fear?

According to an unverified passage, the caciques of Cempoala and those of the Totonac tongue feared that Montezuma's forces would come from Mexico to attack them over the jailing of his tribute-gatherers.7That fear suggests that, within the account, Montezuma's capacity to strike back still weighed on the caciques.7The passage describes a feared reaction, so it does not show that such an attack ever took place.7

Who supposedly wanted to hand the kingdom to Cacamatzin?

An unverified passage names the lords of Coyoacán, Iztapalapa and Tacuba among those taking part in a conspiracy to take the kingdom from Montezuma and give it to Cacamatzin.4According to the same passage, the three lords were Montezuma's nephews.4

If confirmed, the episode would reveal a struggle for power within Montezuma's own family circle.4The passage only allows us to report this, without establishing the motives of those involved or how the alleged conspiracy unfolded or ended.4

How we know

Claims cited: 7 · checked against our sources: 2 · not independently fact-checked: 5.

Sources

  1. Tenochtitlan (the great city of Mexico) was the seat of Montezuma's Mexica power — 'the great city of Tenustitlan, Mexico', and the people of Zocotlan name Montezuma 'their lord'. Projecting the 1519 account onto the 1492 epoch is declared an inference.

    fact-checked primary source

    Bernal Díaz del Castillo, Verdadera historia de los sucesos de la conquista de la Nueva-España (1 de 3) cap88#b16cap62#b14

    back to the text

  2. Tlaxcala was a polity independent of the Mexica in 1492 — a declared inference projected from the 1519 account: 'between their lord Montezuma and the Tlaxcalans there were continuous wars'.

    fact-checked primary source

    Bernal Díaz del Castillo, Verdadera historia de los sucesos de la conquista de la Nueva-España (1 de 3) cap62#b14

    back to the text

  3. Cortés ordered the five tribute-gatherers of Moctezuma arrested and ordered that from then on they neither obey nor give tribute.

    not independently fact-checked primary source

    Bernal Díaz del Castillo, Verdadera historia de los sucesos de la conquista de la Nueva-España (1 de 3) cap47#b1

    back to the text

  4. The lords of Coyoacán, Iztapalapa and Tacuba, nephews of the great Moctezuma, were in the conspiracy to take his kingdom and give it to Cacamatzin.

    not independently fact-checked primary source

    Bernal Díaz del Castillo, Verdadera historia de los sucesos de la conquista de la Nueva-España (1 de 3) cap100#b21

    back to the text

  5. The Tlaxcalans said they were enemies of Moctezuma’s Mexicans, who were not to come to Tlaxcala.

    not independently fact-checked primary source

    Bernal Díaz del Castillo, Verdadera historia de los sucesos de la conquista de la Nueva-España (1 de 3) cap81#b4

    back to the text

  6. The great Moctezuma was given to understand that from many lands they gave parias and tribute to the King, and that it is custom that obedience is first given before parias and tribute are given.

    not independently fact-checked primary source

    Bernal Díaz del Castillo, Verdadera historia de los sucesos de la conquista de la Nueva-España (1 de 3) cap101#b2

    back to the text

  7. The caciques of Cempoal and of the Totonac tongue feared Mexico’s forces under great Moctezuma would come upon them for the jailing of his tax-gatherers.

    not independently fact-checked primary source

    Bernal Díaz del Castillo, Verdadera historia de los sucesos de la conquista de la Nueva-España (1 de 3) cap47#b10

    back to the text