Skip to content

Stories

Alvarado in Accounts of the Conquest: From Cuba to Military References

· AI-assisted · · Leer en español
A small group of travelers approaches a stone gateway in the Andes.
AI-generated illustration based on the sources.

What does Bernal Díaz say about Alvarado in Santiago de Cuba?

Bernal Díaz places Alvarado in Santiago de Cuba alongside Grijalva, Montejo and Ávila, all encomenderos, and notes that Governor Velázquez resided there.1The fragment neither gives Alvarado's first name nor recounts a campaign of his.1

This account places him in that setting, but is insufficient to reconstruct his role in the conquest.1

What does the passage about Gasca's army say?

According to the passage about President Gasca's army, which awaits verification, Marshal Alvarado held the post of maestre de campo.2The same account names Doctor Carvajal as alférez general and Pedro de Villavicencio as sargento mayor, and places the archbishop of Lima and the bishops of Cuzco and Quito beside the president.2

The account assigns Alvarado a title and a military role that do not appear in the testimony about Santiago de Cuba.21Neither fragment establishes a connection between these references, so they do not allow us to conclude that the encomendero in Cuba held that post.12

How does the source describe the fighting at Chuquinga?

According to the account of Chuquinga, which also awaits verification, Francisco Hernández Girón fortified himself in an ancient Indigenous fortress with a main entrance and a rear gate.3The text recounts that Girón feigned flight, that Marshal Alvarado charged with a thousand men, and that a hundred arquebusiers emerged through the rear gate and struck him from behind, without clarifying whom “him” refers to.3

The narrative adds that a single arquebusier killed a hundred men, but introduces this claim with “they say,” presenting it as something reported by others.3That attribution suggests treating the figure as part of the account passed down, without considering it verified.3The shared surname and title of marshal allow us to compare this reference with the one in the account of Gasca's army, although the extracts are insufficient to prove that they concern the same person.32

Who is the Alvarado mentioned among those sentenced?

The passage about the valley of Xaquixaguana (Xacxauana in the source), which awaits verification, dates President Gasca's encounter with Gonzalo Pizarro to 1548 and recounts the latter's surrender.4According to the same source, the following day the Ciancas, Alvarado and Gonzalo Pizarro were sentenced to beheading.4

The fragment neither gives Alvarado's first name nor assigns him the title of marshal.4On this evidence, we cannot attribute the sentence to the encomendero mentioned by Bernal Díaz or to the marshal in the military accounts.4123

What does the reference to the Alvarado River contribute?

According to the coastal description, which awaits verification, the Alvarado River was among the landmarks shown to the pilot, alongside the great Guazacualco River and the San Martín mountains.5The passage neither explains the origin of the river's name nor explicitly connects it to a person.5

The place name alone does not allow us to credit an Alvarado with discovering the river or to connect the account from Cuba with the military references.5123

How we know

Claims cited: 5 · checked against our sources: 1 · not independently fact-checked: 4.

Sources

  1. Santiago de Cuba was the governor's residence: Bernal Díaz says 'they were present at Santiago de Cuba, where Velázquez resided', with Grijalva, Alvarado, Montejo and Ávila, all encomenderos.

    fact-checked primary source

    Bernal Díaz del Castillo, Verdadera historia de los sucesos de la conquista de la Nueva-España (1 de 3) cap08#b2

    back to the text

  2. President Gasca's army had marshal Alvarado as maestre de campo, doctor Carvajal as alférez general and Pedro de Villavicencio as sargento mayor, with the archbishop of Lima and the bishops of Cuzco and Quito beside the president; the muster found seven hundred arquebusiers, five hundred pikemen and four hundred horse — fifteen hundred men at Jauja.

    not independently fact-checked primary source

    Guaman Poma de Ayala, Felipe, c.1535-c.1616, Nueva corónica y buen gobierno (GKS 2232 4º) — kb.dk transcription cap01#b337

    back to the text

  3. Francisco Hernández Girón fortified himself at Chuquinga in 'a fortress of the ancient Indians… which had one main gate and behind it a false gate': he feigned flight, marshal Alvarado charged with a thousand men, and through the false gate a hundred arquebusiers came out and struck from behind — 'they say a single arquebusier killed a hundred men'.

    not independently fact-checked primary source

    Guaman Poma de Ayala, Felipe, c.1535-c.1616, Nueva corónica y buen gobierno (GKS 2232 4º) — kb.dk transcription cap01#b343

    back to the text

  4. In 1548 president Gasca met Gonzalo Pizarro in the valley of Xaquixaguana with nine hundred foot, five hundred horse, five hundred arquebusiers and six artillery pieces; Gonzalo surrendered — 'God wants us to die as Christians' — and the next day they sentenced the Ciancas, Alvarado and Gonzalo Pizarro to beheading, the head carried in an iron cage to Lima.

    not independently fact-checked primary source

    Guaman Poma de Ayala, Felipe, c.1535-c.1616, Nueva corónica y buen gobierno (GKS 2232 4º) — kb.dk transcription cap01#b339

    back to the text

  5. Along the coast the pilot was shown the great river of Guazacualco, the snowy sierras, the sierras of San Martín, the split rock and the Alvarado river.

    not independently fact-checked primary source

    Bernal Díaz del Castillo, Verdadera historia de los sucesos de la conquista de la Nueva-España (1 de 3) cap36#b17

    back to the text