Stories
Diego Colón, Second Admiral: Privileges and Disputes over Authority

Who was Diego Colón, and who might he be confused with?
The account of Ayllón presents Diego Colón as the second admiral and describes his disputes with the judges of the Audiencia of Santo Domingo.2Las Casas mentions another Diego Colón, an Indigenous interpreter taken from Guanahaní during the first voyage and brought to Castile.3The same passage records, with Las Casas expressing uncertainty about his recollection, that the interpreter had returned and spent years among the Spaniards.3
What did he demand in the Columbian lawsuits?
The source on the Columbian lawsuits describes them as a legal dispute that Diego Colón brought against the king to demand that his father's privileges and status be honored.1According to that source, the dispute continued until 1536, and the crown's prosecutor even questioned whether Diego's father had discovered the mainland.1
How did Las Casas use testimony from the lawsuit?
Las Casas invokes the witnesses called by the king's prosecutor in Diego Colón's lawsuit to support his accusation of falsehood against Américo.4According to Las Casas, Américo attributed an arrival at Hispaniola to his second voyage, which the friar declares false.4
Why did he clash with the judges of Santo Domingo?
According to the account of Ayllón, the disputes between Diego Colón and the judges of Santo Domingo centered on jurisdiction.2The passage identifies Villalobos, Matienco, Ayllón and Lebrón as judges of the Audiencia when the admiral returned.2The same account attributes particular anger toward Ayllón to Diego Colón, who believed that Ayllón's reports had harmed him despite their friendship.2It also recounts that Ayllón went to Spain, where the monarch granted him the captaincy-general and governorship and the habit of the Order of Santiago.2
What did he decide about Cuba in 1511?
According to the account of Cuba, Diego Colón decided to send men to settle the island in 1511.5The account states that Diego Velázquez departed from the town of Çabana with 300 men and landed at the port of Palmas.5The source places the landing in the territory ruled by Hatuey and adds that he had fled Hispaniola.5
What does Oviedo recount about the rebellion at Diego Colón's sugar mill?
Oviedo recounts a rebellion begun by enslaved Black people at Diego Colón's sugar mill and specifies that not all those held by the admiral took part at its outset.6The chronicler says he learned what happened from people involved in the events and presents the uprising as a great novelty on the island that foreshadowed grave harm.6
How we know
Claims cited: 6 · checked against our sources: 0 · not independently fact-checked: 6.
Sources
The 'pleitos colombinos' were the lawsuit Diego Colón brought against the king for fulfilment of his father's privileges and estate; the fiscal went so far as to doubt Columbus had discovered the mainland, and the dispute lasted until 1536.
not independently fact-checked primary source
Bartolomé de las Casas, Historia de las Indias (vol. 1 de 5) cap33#b3:498974-500017
Mariano González Clavero, Roberto Blanco Andrés, América española. Descubrimiento, conquista y asentamiento OEBPS/Text/part0028.xhtml#b2
The second admiral don Diego Colón back in Santo Domingo, the Audiencia judges were Villalobos, Matienco, Ayllón and Lebrón; there was no lack of contention between the admiral and the oidores over jurisdiction, and Ayllón went to Spain —where His Majesty granted him the captaincy-general and governorship and gave him the habit of Santiago—; and the admiral held his greatest grievance against Ayllón, 'believing he had done him harm with his reports, being much his friend'.
not independently fact-checked primary source
Gonzalo Fernández de Oviedo y Valdés, Historia General y Natural de las Indias, islas y tierra-firme del Mar Océano cap26#b15cap26#b16
The Admiral's Indian interpreter was "a Diego Colón, one of those the first voyage took at Guanahaní" and carried to Castile and back — "as I believe," says LC — who lived years among the Spaniards.
not independently fact-checked primary source
Bartolomé de las Casas, Historia de las Indias (vol. 2 de 5) cap13#b2:100364-101286
'Hereby our Américo is clearly enough convicted of falsehood', Las Casas argues: of the island they scandalized and harmed he says they returned to Castile without mentioning having first come to this Española, 'which coming he applies to his second voyage, but it is not true, as in chapter 162 I proved above' — he proves it, he says, by the King's Fiscal's witnesses in admiral Diego Colón's suit.
not independently fact-checked primary source
Bartolomé de las Casas, Historia de las Indias (vol. 2 de 5) cap83#b1:787285-787908
In the year 1511 admiral don Diego Colón determined to send men to settle the island of Cuba; Diego Velázquez departed with his 300 men from the villa of Çabana, and went to disembark at the port of Palmas, in the land where Hatuey reigned, who had fled from Española.
not independently fact-checked primary source
Bartolomé de las Casas, Historia de las Indias (vol. 4 de 5) cap02#b1:4319-5072
Bartolomé de las Casas, Historia de las Indias (vol. 3 de 5) cap88#b1:871024-871806
Oviedo calls 'a case of great novelty on this island, and the beginning of much harm' the rebellion of the blacks of admiral don Diego Colón's mill, a rising 'begun by his slaves (and not by all those he had)'; he says he learned it 'from persons who put their hands in it'.
not independently fact-checked primary source
Gonzalo Fernández de Oviedo y Valdés, Historia General y Natural de las Indias, islas y tierra-firme del Mar Océano cap26#b1cap26#b2
leyenda-dorada · https://leyendadorada.com/en/stories/diego-colon-lawsuits-and-authority · accessed November 22, 2026



