Skip to content

Stories

Santo Domingo: A Geography of Voyages, Sugar and Jurisdictions

· AI-assisted · · Leer en español
A canoe and cane stalks beside a tropical estuary and a small settlement.
AI-generated illustration based on the sources.

What does Bernal Díaz recount about the ship that left Santo Domingo?

Bernal Díaz recounts that a ship had sailed from Santo Domingo to capture Lucayans for enslavement and was wrecked beside the river his account links to the port of Matanzas.1According to this account, the Indigenous people ferrying the Spaniards in canoes capsized them in mid-river and killed the Spaniards, an episode to which Bernal Díaz attributes the port's name.1

The passage presents Santo Domingo as the departure point for an expedition linked to enslavement, which Bernal Díaz connects to the origin of the name of the port of Matanzas.1

How do the caravels connect Santo Domingo with Cádiz?

The account recorded by Las Casas places the caravels' departure from Santo Domingo for Castile in early October 1500, with the Admiral aboard as a prisoner and his brothers also on board.2The text dates their arrival in Cádiz to November 20 or 25, without settling on a single day.2

According to Las Casas, Alonso de Vallejo and the shipmaster Andrés Martín de la Gorda treated the Admiral well during the voyage and wanted to remove his shackles, but he preferred to wait until the monarchs ordered their removal.2Las Casas notes that he had heard the story told, recording how the news reached him.2

What do the passages say about sugar in Santo Domingo?

The passage about sugar credits the bachelor Vellosa with producing it in Santo Domingo around 1516.3The same source states that Aguilón, a resident of La Vega, had made the first sugar in the Indies on Hispaniola around 1505–1506.3

These references place the activity attributed to Santo Domingo within a sequence of sugar production, although the excerpt gives no production figures and identifies neither buyers nor export destinations.3

What was disputed in Santo Domingo?

The account of the return of Diego Columbus, the second admiral, to Santo Domingo mentions disputes with the judges of the Audiencia over jurisdiction.4According to that passage, one of the judges was Ayllón, who traveled to Spain and received the captaincy-general and governorship from His Majesty.4

The source adds that Diego Columbus was especially angry with Ayllón because he believed Ayllón's reports had harmed him, despite the friendship they had shared.4The account allows us to interpret Santo Domingo as a setting for disputes over authority also connected to journeys and decisions made in Spain.4

Do all mentions of Santo Domingo refer to the same place?

Not all of them: in the passages about Chacama and Chincha, Santo Domingo appears as the name of monasteries in the places those texts describe.56The passage about the Chacama valley describes abundant sugarcane fields, sugar production and a monastery of Santo Domingo founded by Friar Domingo de Santo Tomás.5The account of Chincha mentions a monastery of Santo Domingo and states that the leading caciques had converted to Christianity.6

Oviedo recounts that Las Casas took the habit of the Observant Dominicans at the monastery of Santo Domingo.7The references to the monasteries of Chacama and Chincha are insufficient to provide geographical information about the Santo Domingo of the sea voyages.56Oviedo's passage does not say where the monastery stood, so it cannot be assigned to one place or another.7

What are the limits of this geography?

The passages allow us to trace the voyages, productive activity and conflicts over authority they recount, but they offer neither a description of Santo Domingo's terrain nor a definition of its territorial boundaries.1234

How we know

Claims cited: 7 · checked against our sources: 1 · not independently fact-checked: 6.

Sources

  1. The port of Matanzas owes its name to a slaughter of Spaniards: Bernal Díaz recounts that a ship that had gone from Santo Domingo 'to fetch Indians, whom they called the Lucayos' — a slave-raiding voyage — wrecked by that river, and that the Indians who came to ferry the survivors 'capsized their canoes in mid-river and killed them'; 'for this cause this port was given the name puerto de Matanzas'.

    fact-checked primary source

    Bernal Díaz del Castillo, Verdadera historia de los sucesos de la conquista de la Nueva-España (1 de 3) cap08#b9cap08#b10cap08#b11

    back to the text

  2. The caravels left Santo Domingo for Castile with the Admiral prisoner and his brothers at the start of October 1500, reaching Cádiz on November 20–25; on the way they were well treated by Alonso de Vallejo and the Maestre Andrés Martín de la Gorda, who 'would have taken off his shackles, but the Admiral did not consent until the Kings should order them removed' — 'as I heard said in that time', Las Casas keeps.

    not independently fact-checked primary source

    Bartolomé de las Casas, Historia de las Indias (vol. 2 de 5) cap97#b1

    back to the text

  3. The first sugar in the Indies was made on Hispaniola around 1505-1506 by a La Vega settler named Aguilón, and around 1516 the bachelor Vellosa made it in Santo Domingo.

    not independently fact-checked primary source

    Bartolomé de las Casas, Historia de las Indias (vol. 5 de 5) cap07#b1:55900-57038

    back to the text

  4. The second admiral don Diego Colón back in Santo Domingo, the Audiencia judges were Villalobos, Matienco, Ayllón and Lebrón; there was no lack of contention between the admiral and the oidores over jurisdiction, and Ayllón went to Spain —where His Majesty granted him the captaincy-general and governorship and gave him the habit of Santiago—; and the admiral held his greatest grievance against Ayllón, 'believing he had done him harm with his reports, being much his friend'.

    not independently fact-checked primary source

    Gonzalo Fernández de Oviedo y Valdés, Historia General y Natural de las Indias, islas y tierra-firme del Mar Océano cap26#b15cap26#b16

    back to the text

  5. In the Chacama valley are many cane-fields yielding much good sugar, and a Dominican monastery founded by fray Domingo de Santo Tomás.

    not independently fact-checked primary source

    Pedro de Cieza de León, La crónica del Perú (1922) cap66#b2:484543-485447

    back to the text

  6. The Chincha people say that at a rock they heard an oracle, and held sacred the place they call Chincha y Camay, always making it sacrifices; today the chief caciques have turned Christian and there is a Dominican monastery.

    not independently fact-checked primary source

    Pedro de Cieza de León, La crónica del Perú (1922) cap72#b2:512862-513857

    back to the text

  7. Oviedo recounts that Las Casas, 'knowing the bad outcome that on his part there was' and the bad account of the hacienda 'left in such poor guard', took the habit of Santo Domingo de la Observancia in the Santo Domingo monastery, 'and in truth held for a good religious: and so I believe he will be better than captain of Cumaná'.

    not independently fact-checked primary source

    Gonzalo Fernández de Oviedo y Valdés, Historia General y Natural de las Indias, islas y tierra-firme del Mar Océano cap258#b13

    back to the text