Stories
Jamaica: from the island of Santiago to the charge of depopulation

What happened to Jamaica's Indigenous people, according to these fragments?
According to the quoted fragment, the island of Jamaica was destroyed and depopulated, and the text blames this on Juan de Esquivel's men.1Read together with the passage about the constant deaths of its Indigenous people, the loss of population is at the heart of what these texts say about the island.12The verb "depopulate" stresses how serious the accusation is, but the text gives no count of inhabitants or of the dead.1
What name did Columbus give Jamaica?
According to another fragment, Columbus named Jamaica Santiago.3The passage credits him with the name but does not explain why he chose it.3
Who is accused of depopulating the island?
The quoted text names Juan de Esquivel's men and adds that it is "truer" to say they went to depopulate the island.1This wording can be read as a challenge to the very purpose of the group's presence there, a purpose the text reduces to depopulating the island.1The fragment identifies the group only by Juan de Esquivel's name, without listing its members or tracing the alleged destruction step by step.1
What does the passage that mentions 1511 add?
According to that passage, the Indigenous people of Jamaica were perishing constantly, as were those of Sant Juan and of another island that the fragment calls "this island" without naming it.2The sentence conveys ongoing mortality but gives no rates or figures by which to measure it.2
The same text states that in 1511 the pestilence had not yet reached Cuba. It also links the complaint to certain laws that, it says, the consultants endorsed by appealing to God and their consciences.2Placing the two side by side suggests a tension between the moral endorsement of the laws and the deaths described, although the excerpt does not say what those laws contained.2
What remains unclear?
The fragments offer no population figures from which to calculate how many people died in Jamaica.12The only mention of the pestilence refers to Cuba, and it is not enough to identify a particular disease or to explain the deaths in Jamaica.2On their own, these passages do not show that no Indigenous people at all remained in Jamaica.12
Questions and answers
- Who called Jamaica Santiago?
- According to the quoted fragment, it was Columbus who named the island of Jamaica Santiago.3
- Whom do the fragments blame for the depopulation of Jamaica?
- The quoted text blames Juan de Esquivel's men for the destruction and depopulation of the island.1
How we know
Claims cited: 3 · checked against our sources: 0 · not independently fact-checked: 3.
Sources
"By those same terms the island of Jamaica was destroyed and depopulated" by Juan de Esquivel's men — "certainly it is truer that they went to depopulate it."
not independently fact-checked primary source
Bartolomé de las Casas, Historia de las Indias (vol. 3 de 5) cap56#b1:546564-547654
"The Indians of this island, and Sant Juan's and Jamaica's, perishing every day and every hour" — Cuba not yet entered by "the pestilence" in 1511 — under laws the consultants affirmed "in God and their consciences."
not independently fact-checked primary source
Bartolomé de las Casas, Historia de las Indias (vol. 3 de 5) cap87#b2:858903-860010
Columbus named the island of Jamaica "Santiago".
not independently fact-checked primary source
Bartolomé de las Casas, Historia de las Indias (vol. 2 de 5) cap13#b2:104420-104768
leyenda-dorada · https://leyendadorada.com/en/stories/jamaica-santiago-depopulation-indigenous-people · accessed November 22, 2026


