Skip to content

Stories

Cádiz in Columbus's fleets: preparations, news and the return of the Admiral as a prisoner

· AI-assisted · · Leer en español
Sailing ships and supplies at a Cádiz quay in the late fifteenth century.
AI-generated illustration based on the sources.

What do we know about the second fleet in the channel of Cádiz?

Ferdinand Columbus places the mustering of his father's second fleet in the channel of Cádiz in September 1493.1The knowledge bank's only attestation of this is a single passage in an uncorrected OCR edition, so the spelling of the place name and the exact day need to be checked against a facsimile.1

What role did Seville and Cádiz share in the preparations?

According to a passage from Las Casas that has not yet been fact-checked, the Monarchs gave the Admiral the necessary dispatches for Seville and Cádiz to prepare his fleet.2The extract links these preparations to the purchase of four topsail ships and the gathering of 140 men.2

The extract does not allow the four ships or the 140 men to be credited to Cádiz alone.2Nor does it allow these figures to be identified with the fleet of September 1493, because neither passage explicitly makes that connection.21

What reached Cádiz with Antonio de Torres?

According to the extract on Antonio de Torres, which has also not yet been fact-checked, he reached Castile with 12 ships after leaving La Isabela on 2 February.4The same source says he arrived in Cádiz on 8 or 10 April; the extract does not give the year.4

According to this account, the Monarchs were overjoyed to learn that the Admiral was safe and to receive his letters and the gold he sent, which was described as gathered from the mines themselves.4This testimony allows Cádiz to be presented as a place where news, letters and gold arrived, although the extract's missing year makes the episode harder to date precisely.4

How does Las Casas describe the Admiral's return as a prisoner?

According to a passage from Las Casas that has not yet been fact-checked, the caravels left Santo Domingo for Castile in early October 1500, carrying the Admiral as a prisoner along with his brothers.3The account has them reaching Cádiz on 20 or 25 November of that year, without saying which of the two days it was.3

The author says that Alonso de Vallejo and the ship's master Andrés Martín de la Gorda treated them well during the voyage.3According to what he says he heard at the time, both men wanted to remove the Admiral's shackles, but he refused until the Monarchs ordered them taken off.3

How we know

Claims cited: 4 · checked against our sources: 1 · not independently fact-checked: 3.

About the sources, per our source records: one register — Castilian chronicle/court-document attestation; not two independent registers

Sources

  1. Fernando Colón places the mustering of his father's second fleet in the channel of Cadiz, in September 1493. The bank's attestation is this single passage in an uncorrected-OCR edition: it carries the event and the year of the second voyage; the name's exact written form and the day-level date are not asserted without facsimile collation.

    fact-checked primary source

    Fernando Colón, Historia del almirante don Cristóbal Colón (tomo I) cap36#b3

    back to the text

  2. Sevilla and Cádiz were the provisioning bases of the Indies run: Las Casas says the Monarchs gave the Admiral 'all the provisions necessary for Sevilla and Cádiz for the expedition of his fleet', where he bought four gavia-rigged vessels and gathered 140 men.

    not independently fact-checked primary source

    Bartolomé de las Casas, Historia de las Indias (vol. 3 de 5) cap04#b3:54529-55548

    back to the text

  3. The caravels left Santo Domingo for Castile with the Admiral prisoner and his brothers at the start of October 1500, reaching Cádiz on November 20–25; on the way they were well treated by Alonso de Vallejo and the Maestre Andrés Martín de la Gorda, who 'would have taken off his shackles, but the Admiral did not consent until the Kings should order them removed' — 'as I heard said in that time', Las Casas keeps.

    not independently fact-checked primary source

    Bartolomé de las Casas, Historia de las Indias (vol. 2 de 5) cap97#b1

    back to the text

  4. Antonio de Torres reached Castile with 12 ships, having left la Isabela February 2 and reached Cádiz April 8 or 10; the Kings received inestimable joy to know the Admiral safe, for his letters and for the gold he sent 'gathered from the very mines'.

    not independently fact-checked primary source

    Bartolomé de las Casas, Historia de las Indias (vol. 2 de 5) cap21#b1

    back to the text