Stories
Xaraguá: Behechio, Anacaona and Accounts of Colonial Violence

Where was Xaraguá and who ruled it?
Xaraguá was one of Hispaniola's province-chiefdoms, ruled by Behechio; the supplied passage mentions both a settlement and the province's territory.1The passage recounts Bartholomew Columbus's mission, dated to around 1496–1498 in the supplied editorial dating.1Extending that political description back to 1492 requires an inference, since the excerpt offers no observation dated to that year.1According to a passage awaiting verification, Xaraguá lay sixty leagues from Santo Domingo.4
That same passage describes a large gathering to welcome Don Bartholomew, attended by Behechio, his sister Anacaona and numerous lords.4The account mentions songs and dances called areitos, and presents Behechio and Anacaona as king and queen.4The scene suggests a public display of authority, although it does not explain how power was shared between the siblings.4
What does the account say about Caonabo and Anacaona?
The passage about Anacaona, still awaiting verification, identifies her as Caonabo's wife and Behechio's sister, and places her move to Xaraguá after recounting her husband's death.2According to that account, the adelantado Don Bartholomew decided to send Caonabo and his brother to Spain in two caravels because he considered it inadvisable to keep so important a lord detained.2The account states that the brother died a few days after learning of their intended destination and that Caonabo died shortly after the voyage began.2
The same source maintains that Anacaona went to live in Xaraguá, where, as a lady, she was as honored and feared as Behechio himself, and credits her with courage, spirit and wit.2This portrayal allows us to discuss the prestige the narrator attributes to her, but is insufficient to establish her governing powers.2
How does the source connect Roldán's rebellion to Xaraguá?
In a passage awaiting verification, Las Casas records that the Admiral wrote to the monarchs about Roldán's rebellion, the harm and robbery committed by the rebels, and how they had thrown Behechio's Xaraguá into turmoil.5According to the account, that communication traveled aboard five ships that departed on October 18, 1498.5The excerpt thus conveys an explanation of that unrest through a communication from the Admiral, without detailing the events that took place in the province.5
In the same passage, Las Casas states that the ships carried around six hundred enslaved Indigenous people and mentions two hundred enslaved people being handed over to the shipmasters as payment for freight.5The excerpt does not indicate where those people came from or allow us to connect them to those who fled the massacre mentioned in another account.53
What do we know about those who fled the massacre?
Las Casas states that Ovando condemned those who had fled the Xaraguá massacre to slavery.3In this passage, “esclavo” denotes the status of a person condemned to servitude, and Las Casas adds that one of those fugitives was given to him in that condition.3His statement places him within the history he recounts, since he acknowledges having held one of the people enslaved by Ovando's decision.3
This testimony suggests that escaping the massacre did not bring those fugitives safety from colonial violence.3The excerpts about the fugitives' enslavement and Anacaona's move do not establish how the massacre happened, how many people died or whether Anacaona had any connection to it.32
How we know
Claims cited: 5 · checked against our sources: 2 · not independently fact-checked: 3.
Sources
Xaraguá was one of Hispaniola's province-chiefdoms, under king Behechio — 'the city and settlement of Xaraguá… the whole province with king Behechio'. The passage narrates Bartolomé Colón's mission (c. 1496-1498); the projection onto the 1492 epoch is declared an inference.
fact-checked primary source
Bartolomé de las Casas, Historia de las Indias (vol. 2 de 5) cap31#b1:260725-261612
The adelantado don Bartolomé agreed to send Caonabo and his brother to Spain in two caravels, holding it inconvenient to keep him detained being so principal a lord; once they knew they were to go, the brother died within days and Caonabo, out at sea, died a few days' sail on; and his wife Anacaona, Behechio's sister, went to live in Xaragua, 'as honored and feared as a lady as Behechio himself', 'very valiant and of great spirit and wit'.
not independently fact-checked primary source
Gonzalo Fernández de Oviedo y Valdés, Historia General y Natural de las Indias, islas y tierra-firme del Mar Océano cap15#b6cap15#b7
'Esclavo' was the state of one condemned to servitude: Las Casas says Ovando 'condemned them to be slaves' — the fugitives of the Xaraguá slaughter — 'and I had one of them who was given me as such'.
fact-checked primary source
Bartolomé de las Casas, Historia de las Indias (vol. 3 de 5) cap09#b1:109894-111011
Sixty leagues Xaraguá lies from Santo Domingo; at don Bartolomé's arrival came out 'infinite people, and many lords and nobility' with king Behechio and the queen his sister Anacaona, 'singing their songs and doing their dances, which they called areitos', and ahead thirty women the king held as wives.
not independently fact-checked primary source
Bartolomé de las Casas, Historia de las Indias (vol. 2 de 5) cap31#b1:260725-261612cap31#b1:261613-262719
The five ships that sailed on October 18, 1498 —'in which my father went to Castile', Las Casas writes— went loaded with Indians made slaves, 'they would be in all 600', and for the others' freight he gave the Maestres 200 slaves; in them the Admiral wrote at length to the Kings of Roldán's rebellion and the harms and robberies they did, and that they had the Xaraguá of king Behechio in tumult.
not independently fact-checked primary source
Bartolomé de las Casas, Historia de las Indias (vol. 2 de 5) cap70#b1:643485-644428
leyenda-dorada · https://leyendadorada.com/en/stories/xaragua-rulers-colonial-violence · accessed November 22, 2026




